Strategy · Systems · Stories Podcast

How to Connect with Audiences in the Age of AI with Ashley Faus

Ashley Faus, author of Human-Centered Marketing, joins Mike Montague to explore trust, authentic thought leadership, and why the customer journey looks more like a playground. Discover practical ways to connect with audiences, build credibility, and use AI to amplify human relationships.

Podcast episode 11 min read

Why trust, authentic thought leadership, and a playground approach to the customer journey matter more than ever.

I recently had Ashley Faus on the Human-First AI Marketing® Podcast, and we got into a topic that has been bothering me for a while. With all the artificial intelligence, automation, content creation tools, and marketing technology available today, why are we still struggling so much to connect with actual humans?

Ashley is a marketing leader at Atlassian, a speaker, and the award-winning author of Human-Centered Marketing: How to Connect with Audiences in the Age of AI. She’s spent years challenging some of the marketing practices we’ve come to accept as gospel, especially the traditional sales funnel, our obsession with attribution, and the way we manufacture thought leadership.

Her perspective lines up remarkably well with what we’re building at Avenue9 through Human-First AI Marketing®. We both believe that understanding people and earning their trust should guide our marketing decisions, especially as AI changes how we create content, find information, and make buying decisions.

We covered a lot of ground, including playground equipment, theatrical performances, ghostwriters, AI-generated content, and why marketers keep chasing algorithms. Here are seven lessons I think every business owner and marketing director should consider.

1. Trust Is Built on Authenticity, Competence, and Empathy

Ashley referenced Harvard Business School professor Frances Frei’s framework for trust, which identifies three essential ingredients: authenticity, competence, and empathy.

Competence means people believe you can deliver what you promise. Empathy means they believe you understand and care about their needs. Authenticity means they believe they’re getting to know the real you.

That last one gets particularly interesting when we bring AI into the conversation.

Ashley pointed out that AI can demonstrate considerable competence and mimic the language of empathy. After all, we teach children how to express empathy by showing them what to say and how to behave. AI has access to those same linguistic patterns.

Authenticity is a deeper challenge because it comes from your actual experiences, personality, beliefs, and decisions.

I shared a story about a client who wanted to add an AI humanizer to their already AI-generated content because it sounded too artificial. I found the idea pretty funny. They wanted to use another layer of artificial intelligence to manufacture authenticity.

For small businesses, this is an important distinction. You already have something your larger competitors may struggle to capture consistently: direct access to the people who built your company, serve your customers, and know your industry.

The lesson: Capture your real expertise, opinions, customer interactions, and stories before asking AI to help create marketing content. Those experiences give your content its authenticity.

2. You Can Have a Ghostwriter, but You Can’t Have a Ghost Thinker

This was probably my favorite quote from Ashley during the interview:

“You can have a ghostwriter, you cannot have a ghost thinker.”

Ashley has developed a framework around four pillars of thought leadership: credibility, profile, being prolific, and depth of ideas.

That fourth pillar deserves special attention. Genuine thought leadership comes from experiencing problems, developing new solutions, learning from failures, and helping people think or act in a new direction.

AI can help us research, organize, articulate, and distribute those ideas. The original insight still needs to come from someone who understands the problem and has something meaningful to contribute.

I’ve spent years ghostwriting for executives and business owners, and the best content always starts with a conversation. I interview the expert, ask about their experiences, explore what they believe, and help them articulate ideas they may have never put into words.

We use that same process at Avenue9 today, with AI helping us turn those conversations into articles, podcasts, videos, newsletters, and sales content.

This is the foundation of our A9^Factor Framework, which combines human-first strategy, AI marketing systems, and scalable storytelling.

Think about the expertise sitting inside your company right now. Your salespeople know the objections customers raise. Your service team knows the problems people encounter. Your leadership team has learned lessons through years of experience.

The lesson: Interview your experts before creating content. Ask them what they’ve learned recently, what conventional wisdom they disagree with, and what customers consistently misunderstand. Use AI to help turn those ideas into useful marketing assets.

3. The Customer Journey Is a Playground

Ashley is well known for her playground framework, which challenges the traditional linear marketing funnel.

I love this analogy because it reflects how actual people behave.

When kids arrive at a playground, they don’t follow a prescribed sequence. One heads straight for the swings, another climbs the jungle gym, and someone else sits on a bench until they’re ready to participate.

They move around, revisit their favorite activities, watch other people, and leave whenever they want.

Your customers behave the same way.

Someone might listen to your podcast for six months before visiting your website. Another person might find you through a colleague’s recommendation, read one customer story, and request a proposal that afternoon. A third might follow your CEO on LinkedIn for years before becoming a prospect.

Most marketing funnels assume we can move people through predictable stages and measure every interaction along the way. Ashley’s framework encourages us to create useful experiences that allow people to explore in whatever order makes sense to them.

This is especially important for B2B companies with long sales cycles and multiple decision-makers.

The lesson: Build a marketing playground with multiple entry points. Offer educational resources, customer stories, videos, community experiences, and opportunities to speak with a real person. Make it easy for buyers to find the information they need at their own pace.

4. Your Dashboard Might Be Teaching You to Market to Robots

One of the most interesting parts of our conversation was Ashley’s explanation of why marketers become obsessed with algorithms.

It’s largely a measurement problem.

When marketing directors walk into leadership meetings, they need to demonstrate progress. Website visits, impressions, clicks, engagement rates, and conversions are relatively easy to measure, so those numbers dominate the conversation.

Unfortunately, the behaviors that actually build relationships can be much harder to track.

You might meet someone at a conference who recommends your company to a colleague three months later. That colleague visits your website, reads an article, and eventually becomes a customer.

Your analytics software may credit the website visit while overlooking the conversation that created the opportunity.

Ashley explained how this pressure encourages marketers to optimize for the activities that are easiest to measure. Eventually, teams start making decisions around what performs well in dashboards and social media algorithms.

I’ve been guilty of this myself. When you’ve spent decades in digital marketing, it’s easy to become fascinated by the numbers. I still love a good dashboard, but I’ve become increasingly interested in the conversations and relationships happening behind those numbers.

The lesson: Keep measuring performance, but include human indicators of progress. Track qualified sales conversations, referrals, customer recommendations, event relationships, and the actual questions prospects ask before buying.

Ask your newest customers how they first heard about you and what convinced them to reach out. Their answers may reveal some of your most effective marketing activities.

5. Respect Your Audience’s Intent

Ashley shared a simple principle that every marketer should remember: your calls to action should match what your audience actually wants to do.

We’ve all experienced the opposite.

You click a button labeled “Learn More” and immediately encounter a sales form. You download an educational resource and suddenly receive a series of aggressive sales emails. You browse a product once and spend the next three months being followed around the internet by ads.

These experiences create friction because the company is trying to advance the sale before the customer has expressed that intention.

Ashley encouraged marketers to make their calls to action clear and explicit. If someone wants to learn, help them learn. If they want to compare solutions, make that information available. When they’re ready to talk with sales, make that next step easy.

This fits perfectly with our approach to Human-First AI Marketing®. We want to use AI to make the customer experience more relevant and helpful while respecting the person on the other side of the screen.

For example, our free Human+AI Trust Score gives business owners a way to assess their website’s trust signals and identify areas for improvement. It’s designed to provide useful information they can act on, regardless of whether they eventually work with us.

The lesson: Review the calls to action on your website, emails, and landing pages. Make sure each one delivers the experience it promises and gives your audience a clear, appropriate next step.

6. People and AI Both Need Reasons to Trust You

During our conversation, I shared some of the thinking behind Avenue9’s Human+AI Trust Score, which evaluates signals that help people and AI systems assess a brand’s credibility.

Ashley raised an important point about customer stories and testimonials: can people actually verify the claims you’re making?

Anyone can publish a glowing testimonial or claim extraordinary results. Credibility grows when those statements are supported by recognizable people, specific experiences, and evidence that others can check.

For example, a testimonial from an identifiable customer with a real role and company provides useful context. A case study describing the actual challenge, solution, and measurable outcome gives buyers something concrete to evaluate.

These signals also matter as buyers increasingly use AI assistants to research potential vendors. AI systems may draw on external reviews, independent mentions, published examples, and other accessible evidence when generating responses or recommendations.

I’ve been exploring this idea through our Trust Tree approach to Answer Engine Optimization. Your reputation develops through authenticity, reliability, credibility, and generosity, supported by consistent stories and evidence across the places people research your business.

The underlying principle is simple: give people good reasons to recommend you, and make those reasons easy to discover and verify.

The lesson: Audit your trust signals. Feature real employees, identifiable customer testimonials, detailed case studies, relevant credentials, and credible third-party endorsements. Make sure your claims are accurate and supported by evidence.

7. Great Marketers Know How to Read the Room

Ashley has a background in musical theater, and we had a fun conversation about the connection between performing and marketing.

As an ensemble performer, she spends time understanding different characters, their motivations, and how they experience particular moments.

That same discipline translates directly into marketing.

When Ashley thinks about a potential customer, she considers the person’s situation, goals, frustrations, and motivations. A buyer may want to save time, advance their career, solve a frustrating operational problem, or reduce risk for their organization.

Understanding those motivations gives marketers a much stronger foundation for creating relevant messages.

Public speaking also provides something digital marketers often struggle to obtain: immediate human feedback.

When you’re on stage, you can see whether people are engaged, confused, amused, or completely lost. Online, a weak response might mean your idea missed the mark, your timing was poor, or the algorithm simply failed to distribute your content.

I think this is one reason in-person events, workshops, customer interviews, and real conversations remain so valuable.

The lesson: Spend more time talking with customers and listening to their stories. Encourage your marketing team to participate in sales calls, customer meetings, and industry events. Those interactions help you understand what your audience cares about and how to communicate with them.

What This Means for Small Business Marketing in the Age of AI

One of the things I appreciated most about Ashley’s perspective is that she understands the realities of modern marketing. We need to generate leads, support sales, demonstrate results, and accomplish all of that with limited time and resources.

For small and midsized businesses, AI creates an extraordinary opportunity to extend what a relatively small marketing team can accomplish.

You can turn a founder interview into a month’s worth of useful content. You can analyze customer conversations to identify recurring questions and objections. You can personalize educational content for different industries and buying situations. You can free your team from repetitive production tasks so they have more time for creativity, strategy, and relationships.

The value compounds when those systems are built around genuine human expertise and a clear understanding of your audience.

Ashley and I share a belief that trust should guide these decisions. Her human-centered marketing frameworks help explain how people explore, evaluate, and connect with brands. Our Human-First AI Marketing® approach at Avenue9 helps businesses use AI to support those experiences consistently and affordably.

The next time you’re reviewing your marketing strategy, consider spending an hour talking with your customers before spending another hour testing an AI tool. You may discover that the most valuable ideas for your next campaign have been sitting inside your business all along.

And if you want to put those ideas to work, Avenue9 helps expert-led businesses turn their knowledge and customer conversations into content, trust, and new clients.

Keep the Conversation Going

I really enjoyed this conversation with Ashley Faus, and I encourage you to explore her work. Her book, Human-Centered Marketing: How to Connect with Audiences in the Age of AI, offers a practical look at building trust, rethinking customer journeys, developing thought leadership, and creating meaningful audience engagement.

You can also visit AshleyFaus.com and connect with Ashley on LinkedIn, where she regularly shares ideas about marketing, leadership, and the humans behind the screen.

If you’re curious how much trust your own brand is building, try our free Human+AI Trust Score. You’ll get a clearer picture of how your website demonstrates credibility to human buyers and AI systems, along with practical opportunities for improvement.

Let’s talk

Human conversations still matter. Let’s have one.